Summary of RSK Wilding’s response
RSK Wilding objects to the draft Environmental Delivery Plan (EDP) and asks Natural England not to recommend it to the Secretary of State in its current form. Because this plan is the template for 15 further nutrient EDPs, we also ask that the programme be paused and independently reviewed before any EDP is made.
About us: RSK Wilding is the nature recovery business of RSK Group. We advise landowners, developers and public bodies on biodiversity protection, mitigation and compensation through the development and planning process. Through RSK Biocensus we act as a Responsible Body under Part 7 of the Environment Act 2021, holding conservation covenants that secure habitat banks across England. That work shows us what it takes to quantify, secure, monitor and enforce environmental outcomes over decades.
Declaration of interest: We, like many organisations operating in this area, could be awarded lucrative contracts by Natural England under proposed EDPs. They would be lucrative, in particular, because there is no requirement to deliver measured, or measurable ecologically beneficial outcomes in return for payments. However, despite the financial incentive to support this overall approach, we strongly oppose this due to the significant ecological degradation that the EDPs have been designed to accelerate.
Our main points
- The plan lets nutrient loads rise at sites that need them to fall: On the plan’s figures, after every measure is delivered, 270–435 kg of phosphorus and 7,695 kg of nitrogen a year still reach the sites: 29–39% of the added phosphorus and 83% of the added nitrogen, for as long as the homes are occupied. The sites need phosphorus inputs cut by up to 97%.
- The plan’s largest quantified benefit has no published method: Phosphorus “retained by restored habitat” in created fen, 365.8 kg a year, supplies 55% of the quantified phosphorus benefit. Natural England’s document update withdraws the only reference to a method document (paragraph 858) and points to measure specifications and land use change instead; we can find no derivation of the fen figures anywhere in the plan. Without the fen figures, 68–73% of the added phosphorus is unaddressed.
- The plan substitutes management actions for pollution control: Where nutrients limit the condition of a habitat, as the draft’s evidence shows they do here, no amount of deer or habitat management can recover irreplaceable fen or a chalk river until the pollution source is cut. The measures that cut pollution were discounted, although the Norfolk councils’ credit company contracted 550 kg a year of permanent phosphorus reduction from septic tank upgrades in 2025.
- The plan applies a lower standard than Natural England applies to itself: Natural England sells permanent nutrient credits in these catchments, quantified in kilograms and secured for up to 125 years. The EDP requires no quantified neutrality at all, despite saying it ‘goes beyond neutrality’.
- The plan undercuts verified mitigation, with no impact assessment: The plan’s 80% uptake assumption rests on evidence that the levy “will be cheaper than alternative routes”. It is cheaper because it buys less. No assessment of its effect on the nutrient mitigation market, or on public money already committed to it, has been published.
- The consultation falls short of the Consultation Principles it says it follows: Key evidence is unpublished, the evidence base changed during the consultation, and 28 working days is not proportionate for the first plan of its kind.
What we ask
- Pause the EDP programme until an independent review, informed by the Office for Environmental Protection, has reported.
- Publish the missing evidence (Q28 and Q35), correct the plan, and re-open the consultation for at least six weeks.
- Make quantified nutrient neutrality the floor of the test, by sub-catchment and nutrient and secured before occupation, with improvement measured on top. This would deliver a true ‘overall improvement’.
- Reinstate source control (the best and most effective environmental protection is prevention at source): septic tank and package treatment plant upgrades, buffer strips, treatment wetlands, water efficiency and SuDS conditions.
- Set the levy at the full cost of verified outcomes, independently assessed (as is the case for Community Infrastructure Levies) differentiated by location, and publish the cost model.
- Buy verified and secured outcomes from existing and new suppliers and measure and report them annually.
About you (Q1–Q5)
Q1. Confidentiality
Would you like your response to be confidential?
No
Q2. Key information
- Name: Alexa Culver
- Email address: alexa.culver@rskwilding.com
- Organisation: RSK Wilding (a business unit of RSK Biocensus Limited)
- Role: Legal Counsel
- Location: Suites 1–3, Bank House, Bond’s Mill, Stonehouse GL10 3R
Q3. Interest in this consultation
What best describes your interest in this consultation?
Other: We are interested in this EDP and in EDPs more widely. It is the first EDP, its methods are intended as the template for 15 further nutrient EDPs, and it directly affects the nutrient mitigation and nature markets in which we regulate as a Responsible Body, and advise developers, landowners and public bodies.
Q4. Capacity
Which of the following best describes you or the capacity in which you are responding?
Representative of an organisation; nature market provider; consultant; interested party
Q5. Developers
Not applicable.
Chapters 1 and 2: executive summary and introduction (Q6–Q7)
Q6. Purpose
To what extent do you think the overall purpose of the EDP is sufficiently clear?
Not very clear
The levy discharges an obligation about nutrient pollution, yet the plan says its test is not about “the amount or extent of nutrient pollution” (p.75) and does not consider pollution from agriculture (para 8). A reader cannot tell whether the plan’s purpose is to deal with the pollution its development causes, or to fund habitat management in place of dealing with it.
Q7. Approach to material improvement
To what extent does the Executive summary and the Introduction (chapters 1 and 2) clearly set out the approach the EDP will take to deliver a material improvement that outweighs the negative effect of development?
Not clear at all
Chapters 1 and 2 do not tell the reader that, on the plan’s own annexes, its quantified measures leave 83% of the added nitrogen and 29–39% (or up to 61%) of the added phosphorus unaddressed, every year. Nor do they explain how a permanent net increase in the pressure that limits these sites can be “materially outweighed”. The Government announced the plan as “going beyond neutrality”; its own figures show it does not reach neutrality.
Chapter 3: scope of the EDP (Q8–Q11)
Q8. EDP period
Is the EDP period clearly set out?
No
The ten-year period, and the closure to new commitments after year six, are clear. What the plan does not explain is how a ten-year test relates to an impact that lasts for as long as the homes are occupied (see Q22).
Q9. Geographic scope
To what extent do you agree that the geographic scope of the EDP has been clearly defined?
Not very clear
The boundary follows where housing is expected, not the nutrient system the protected sites depend on. Three consequences need explaining.
First, the Ant, Trinity Broads and Upper Thurne catchments are left out because little development is expected there (para 46), although they are unfavourable for both nitrogen and phosphorus. One connected Broads system will therefore run under two regimes: the levy in some catchments and project-level Habitats Regulations assessment in others. The EDP should map, for developers and mitigation providers alike, exactly where nutrient neutrality continues to apply.
Second, measures and impacts are in different places. 237 of the 256 hectares of wider-catchment land use change are in the Wensum, yet that land is credited in full against both the Wensum and the Yare (paras 751 and 837), with no attenuation for benefit delivered upstream. Most of the Yare’s homes (13,286 of 14,953) discharge below the Wensum confluence (para 527). The plan should require benefit to be delivered where the impact arises, or apply a justified attenuation factor.
Third, wastewater treatment catchments do not match surface water catchments. The EDP should show which works serve EDP homes and where their effluent enters the sites.
We also ask the EDP to state that the load from EDP homes must still be counted when competent authorities assess other plans and projects in combination, and that EDP measures cannot be used as headroom or mitigation by any other plan or project. Otherwise, the same reduction could be counted twice, undermining every verified mitigation scheme in the catchment.
Q10. Excluded areas
To what extent is the explanation and depiction of excluded areas sufficiently clear?
Not very clear
We think three points need clarifying:
First, the plan gives no hydrological evidence for a 50-metre buffer around the sites. Field drains, groundwater and surface runoff can carry nutrients well beyond 50 metres. The buffer should be justified against the pathways at each site.
Second, the plan should say how development in excluded areas, and the 20% of expected housing it assumes will not use the levy (Annex 3A), will be assessed in combination with EDP development. That development will still need verified, project-level mitigation. The EDP should say so plainly, so that the mitigation market serving it remains viable.
Third, the plan expressly permits the development of dwellinghouses only within scope of the levy (para 58), but the Act allows other kinds of development to be covered (s.60). Under section 68, consultation on an amendment adding a kind of development (but not altering the maximum amount of development) would be at the Secretary of State’s discretion, not mandatory (s.68(3)–(4)). Natural England should confirm that no other kind of development will be added to this plan without full public consultation.
Q11. Maximum development capacity
To what extent is the methodology used to define the maximum development capacity (15,780 dwellings) under this Norfolk EDP clearly set out?
Not very clear
The figure of 15,780 homes is a forecast of levy uptake, not a measure of what the protected sites can absorb while recovering. Annex 3A applies 75% for expected delivery and 80% for levy uptake to local housing need of 2,630 homes a year, and says the capacity “is not a limit on the total development that can occur” in the area.
The 80% uptake assumption rests on “emerging evidence that the Nature Restoration Levy will be cheaper than alternative routes to mitigating nutrient impacts” (para 293). That evidence is not published. It assumes the levy will take four-fifths of the demand that verified mitigation schemes now serve. If the levy is cheaper because it buys less mitigation, high uptake is a sign of under-pricing, not efficiency.
A flat charge will also skew uptake. Developments with the highest loads per home, where verified mitigation costs most, gain most from the levy. The average load per levy-paying home will therefore exceed the plan’s assumption, and the programme will be under-funded.
The figures do not reconcile. Bure and Yare homes (831 and 14,953) sum to 15,784, and it is unclear whether the Wensum’s 500 homes are additional. The phasing covers three phases of 5,000 homes, leaving 780 homes without identified measures.
Natural England should publish the MHCLG analysis and uptake evidence, test the plan against uptake from 60% to 100%, and derive capacity from the load the sites can accept while recovering.
Chapter 4: plans and strategies (Q12–Q13)
Q12. Other plans and strategies
Are there any other relevant plans and strategies you think this EDP should take into account?
Yes
- Nutrient mitigation already secured in these catchments: Norfolk Environmental Credits, owned by Breckland, Broadland, North Norfolk, Norwich City and South Norfolk councils, has contracted 550 kg a year of permanent (90-year) phosphorus reduction from septic tank upgrades, in contracts worth £22 million awarded in 2025. It is also buying permanent credits from Natural England’s own land reversion at Foxley Wood, Bawdeswell and Wood Norton (contract value £5 million). The EDP should explain how it interacts with these commitments and with Local Nutrient Mitigation Fund schemes, and how it avoids stranding them.
- Natural England’s own credit standards: When Natural England sells nutrient credits it quantifies them in kilograms and secures them by section 7 agreements or a conservation covenant. The EDP should explain why it does not meet the same standard.
- Statutory water targets: The Environmental Targets (Water) (England) Regulations 2023 require an 80% cut in wastewater phosphorus and a 40% cut in agricultural nutrient loads by 2038. Environmental Improvement Plan commitment 26(b) seeks an 18% cut in agricultural loads by 2030 in catchments with protected sites in unfavourable condition. A permanent net increase sits uneasily with both.
- Biodiversity net gain: Lowland fen is irreplaceable habitat under the Biodiversity Gain Requirements (Irreplaceable Habitat) Regulations 2024. The EDP should also say whether EDP-funded habitat may generate biodiversity units or carbon credits.
- The Farming Rules for Water, the Anglian River Basin Management Plan and Anglian Water’s drainage and wastewater management plan, with dates and expected reductions, because the EDP’s loads assume treatment works upgrades by 2030.
Q13. Measures by other public authorities
To what extent has the EDP provided a clear overview of the measures currently being taken or likely to be taken by other public authorities?
Not very clear
Chapter 4 lists schemes but gives no scale, funding, timing or expected nutrient reductions, and the returns from public authorities under section 63(7) are not published. The reader cannot tell whether the sites will recover, or what part of any improvement the EDP could claim.
Chapter 5: environmental features (Q14–Q17)
Q14. Features identified
To what extent do you agree that all environmental features (habitats and species designated under The Broads SAC, Broadland Ramsar, and River Wensum SAC) likely to be negatively affected by nutrient pollution from development have been identified in the EDP?
Not very clear
First, the plan does not say which features are irreplaceable. Lowland fen is irreplaceable habitat under the Biodiversity Gain Requirements (Irreplaceable Habitat) Regulations 2024, and the draft describes the Broads as holding “the UK’s largest area of calcareous lowland fen” (p.3). The word “irreplaceable” does not appear in the plan. That matters because every measure but one is classified as compensation (para 153), and compensation is not an appropriate response to harm to irreplaceable habitat. The Wensum, a chalk river with water-crowfoot vegetation (H3260), deserves the same recognition.
Second, nitrogen pressure on the Wensum is not assessed because the catchment has “no nitrogen target” (para 28). The absence of a target is not evidence of no effect. Natural England should explain why nitrogen is not relevant to the river and to Desmoulin’s whorl snail.
We share others’ concern that the Ant, Trinity Broads and Upper Thurne sites, and the Waveney valley within the Broadland Ramsar site, are part of one connected wetland system and should be considered in combination.
Natural England assesses every identified feature as deteriorating (para 124), and the chemical component as red or failing wherever it is assessed (paras 314, 348, 384 and 431). For each feature, the plan should say how close it is to the “Black – degraded beyond the point of recovery” category (p.30), since that is the risk the added load creates.
Q15. Defining conservation status
To what extent do you agree with the approach of defining current conservation status of environmental features using habitat structure and function and their future prospects?
Strongly disagree
The approach scores four components of structure and function (physical, hydrological, chemical and biological) and lets gains in some offset losses in others. That is not how these systems behave. Where one pressure limits a feature’s condition, improving the others does not change the outcome.
Nutrient enrichment is a limiting factor in the broads, that prevents ecological recover. Recovery “requires a much larger reduction in nutrients than the increase that created the shift” (para 540). Even small increases risk an “irrecoverable state” (para 548). Dominant tall vegetation is “locking in degraded conditions” (para 562). The sites need phosphorus cuts of 55–97% in the Bure, 87–91% in the Yare and 34–74% in the Wensum (para 27).
No amount of deer or habitat management can recover irreplaceable fen or a chalk river until the nutrient source is cut. Management only changes how a habitat looks for a season. The evidence, including Hilt et al. (2018) on 49 shallow lakes, is that improvements without external load reduction are temporary and the system reverts.
The red-amber-green scale is also inappropriately blunt. It cannot distinguish a feature in slow decline from one near a tipping point. Natural England should publish the measured concentrations and condition data for each feature, as its November 2025 prototype did.
Q16. Description of the negative effect
To what extent do you agree with the description of how the negative effect of additional nutrient loading from new development impacts the environmental features of the protected sites?
Disagree
Annex 5B describes the ecology of nutrient harm well, and we agree with it: responses are non-linear, phosphorus accumulates in sediments, and these shallow lakes are vulnerable to tipping points. Our disagreement is with how that harm is then assessed.
First, the load is set against existing pollution (an increase of 0.4% on monitored concentrations, p.31) rather than against what the sites need. Against the lake target, the phosphorus increase is 5.3% (para 528), at sites that need reductions of up to 97%.
Second, precaution has been removed. The load uses only the post-2030 scenario, which assumes treatment works have been upgraded; the pre-2030 scenario is set aside as “likely an over estimation” (para 523). No precautionary buffer is applied. Natural England’s November 2025 prototype applied a 20% buffer, giving roughly 0.20 kg of phosphorus per home a year against roughly 0.07 kg in the original prototype. Precautionary buffers are essential to any delivery of an ‘overall improvement’ for nature.
Third, the nutrient load is stated twice, differently: 90 and 980 kg of phosphorus a year for the Bure and Yare in Annex 5B (paras 526–527), but 110 and 795 kg in Annex 7B (para 741). It is not possible to tell which figures the programme and the levy were sized against.
Fourth, the harm is permanent. Wastewater flows for as long as the homes are occupied, and phosphorus stored in sediment keeps recycling after inputs fall.
To reflect reality, the plan should use the pre-2030 scenario until upgrades are delivered, apply a buffer given the tipping point risk of irreversible ecosystem collapse, and given the ambitions to deliver ‘overall improvement,’ reconcile the two sets of figures, and present the nutrient loads against the reduction each feature needs.
Q17. Assessment approach
Do you think the approach used to assess the environmental impacts of additional nutrient loading from EDP development on the conservation status of the environmental features is appropriate and proportionate?
No
The approach turns measured quantities into subjective opinion. Development loads are calculated in kilograms a year, then converted, with the effects of measures, into scores from −100 to +100 by a modified Delphi panel (paras 209–210). The panel’s membership, scores, statistical analysis and the record of how the programme changed between rounds are not published. Deer management was added after the first assessment round (Table 6, note), and for open water the margin is as little as one scoring band.
Expert elicitation (using subjective probabilities and judgment in applying the overall improvement test) is appropriate in situations of irreducible uncertainty. But here, elicitation is inappropriately applied to quantities that are measurable and partly measured, and it lets unquantified physical and biological gains outweigh a measured chemical deterioration.
Biodiversity net gain shows the alternative. The statutory biodiversity metric is published, and anyone can rerun a calculation; as a Responsible Body we check habitat bank delivery against those universal metrices. By contrast, no one outside Natural England can rerun the assessment behind this plan.
The modelling also assumes agricultural and other diffuse loads remain at current levels in every scenario. No scenario tests growth in those sources, though they supply most of the load.
A proportionate approach would publish a nutrient budget for each sub-catchment and feature: the development load, the quantified reduction from each measure with uncertainty ranges, delivery dates, and the net position against the target. Nutrient mitigation providers already meet that standard. It should be the minimum for a plan that removes project-level assessment from up to 15,780 homes.
Chapter 6: conservation measures (Q18–Q25)
Q18. The programme of measures
To what extent do you agree that the proposed programme of conservation measures is appropriate to outweigh the negative effect of development?
Strongly disagree
On the plan’s figures, the programme does not offset the pollution it permits, let alone outweigh it. Development adds 938–1,103 kg of phosphorus and 9,306 kg of nitrogen a year. Quantified measures remove about 668 kg and 1,611 kg (Annex 7B, paras 741–751). The remainder, 270–435 kg of phosphorus and 7,695 kg of nitrogen a year, reaches sites that are already failing, permanently.
The quantified benefit is itself fragile. Of the 668 kg, 365.8 kg is phosphorus said to be “retained by restored habitat” in created fen (para 741), for which no method is published (Q28). Without it, 68–73% of the added phosphorus is unaddressed. A further 248.5 kg comes from land in the Wensum credited in full against both the Wensum and the Yare (paras 751 and 837).
No nutrient reduction is quantified for fen management, catch-dyke remediation, deer management, weir removal or river restoration. The draft calls the nutrient benefit of fen creation in the Wensum “likely to be negligible” (paras 831 and 852). No avoidance measures were identified, and every measure but one is compensation, rather than the much more ecologically effective avoidance, and mitigation (para 153).
Deer management is the largest recurring cost, £175,000–£200,000 a year for 20 years, with no quantified nutrient benefit. The 162 hectares of fen management is work on existing SSSI fen in unfavourable condition, already the subject of existing duties and agri-environment provision.
Where nutrients limit a habitat’s condition, these measures cannot deliver recovery. The programme should first secure quantified nutrient neutrality, and then improvement on top.
Q19. Measures not included
Do you have any comments on the conservation measures that were considered by Natural England but not included within the programme of conservation measures, or are there any additional measures that should have been considered?
The measures that would reduce the pollution were discounted, and the reasons do not stand up.
Septic tank and package treatment plant upgrades were rejected for “low potential for local and system-level benefits” and because they do not restore ecosystem “structure, function and resilience” (Table 6, p.46). In 2025 Norfolk Environmental Credits, owned by five Norfolk councils, contracted 550 kg a year of permanent (90-year) phosphorus reduction from septic tank upgrades in the Norfolk nutrient neutrality catchments, to be delivered within 12 to 24 months. That is half to three-fifths of this plan’s entire phosphorus load. The benefit is local, quantified and quick.
Riparian buffer strips were rejected in the same terms. Treatment wetlands and enhanced ditch management, both in Natural England’s November 2025 prototype, are not on the long list.
Water efficiency and sustainable drainage conditions were dropped. Water efficiency was scored red for reasonableness, the cost of compliance being judged to outweigh the benefit (p.184); SuDS was discounted as not additional (p.48). Both reduce load at source. They should be conditions on every EDP home, as the prototype required and as Wildlife and Countryside Link and CIEEM have also argued. While much of the country is suffering unprecedented levels of drought, now is the wrong time to remove water neutrality measures.
Land use change, procured as verified kilograms, should be the core measure.
We ask Natural England to:
- reinstate these measures and rank all measures by verified cost per kilogram;
- buy reductions from existing schemes (Norfolk Environmental Credits, Local Nutrient Mitigation Fund schemes and private suppliers) on fair terms; and
- secure land-based measures by conservation covenant, with safeguards against livestock or manure being displaced elsewhere in the catchment.
Q20. Role of back-up measures
To what extent do you agree that the EDP clearly sets out the role of back-up conservation measures and the circumstances in which they will be implemented?
Disagree
Back-up measures are triggered by qualitative findings, with no thresholds, and the plan does not say how a shortfall would be detected in time when monitoring largely infers outcomes from delivery.
Q21. The back-up measures
To what extent do you agree with the proposed back up conservation measures?
Strongly disagree
The back-up measures are more of the primary measures (para 171). If a primary measure fails, for example if created fen does not retain the phosphorus assumed, delivering more of it is not a remedy.
The triggers are qualitative findings that measures are “unlikely to meet” the test (para 274), with no thresholds, and sequencing is not fixed (para 175). Back-ups are funded only from a 5% contingency (para 227), which could not pay for a significant failure.
Compulsory purchase is the last resort (para 183). Where landowners already supply verified mitigation voluntarily, the prospect of compulsory acquisition for compensation measures will deter the participation the plan depends on.
Back-ups should be different in kind: quantified source reductions bought from the market, with triggers set in kilograms and in measured water quality. If delivery falls behind occupation, new levy commitments should pause automatically until it catches up. The contingency should be sized against realistic failure scenarios, including failure of the fen retention assumption, and that analysis published.
Q22. The 100-year period
To what extent do you agree that 100 years is the appropriate period to secure and maintain conservation measures?
Disagree
The impact lasts for as long as the homes are occupied (para 164), which will be longer than 100 years. Measures that offset a permanent impact should be secured in perpetuity, or at least for the lifetime of the development.
Natural England’s own practice sets a higher bar. The nutrient credits it sells in these catchments from land reversion at Foxley Wood and Wood Norton are secured for 125 years, by agreements under section 7 of the Natural Environment and Rural Communities Act 2006. The EDP asks for less.
As a Responsible Body we see that long-term delivery depends on obligations that bind the land and pass to successors, funded monitoring, enforcement rights held independently of the delivery body, and ring-fenced money that is not exposed to investment shortfalls. For each measure, the EDP should state the relevant legal binding instrument, who holds enforcement rights, and what happens at year 100.
The financial basis also needs work. The levy assumes investment returns that support a 2.05% discount rate over 100 years (paras 229–231). The plan does not say whether the rate is real or nominal, gives no sensitivity analysis, and does not say who meets a shortfall; the 5% contingency is reserved for back-ups. Monitoring falls away after year five and, from year 50, only confirms that maintenance is happening (paras 260–262). Over a century, rising sea levels and saline intrusion in this low-lying catchment may change how created wetland performs; the plan should say how measures will be adapted, and who pays.
Q23. Value for money
To what extent do you agree that Natural England has adequately considered the value for money offered by the conservation measures that have been selected?
Strongly disagree
Value for money has been judged on the cost of activities, not on the nutrient outcome they buy. No cost per kilogram of phosphorus or nitrogen removed is given for any measure, so the selected measures cannot be compared with each other, with the discounted measures, or with the market.
The market provides a benchmark. In 2025 Norfolk Environmental Credits contracted 550 kg a year of permanent phosphorus reduction from septic tank upgrades for £22 million: about £40,000 per kilogram a year, with associated nitrogen. On the plan’s figures, its measure budget (delivery and maintenance, 77% of a £42.2 million levy, about £32.5 million) equates to about £48,700 per kilogram of quantified phosphorus reduction a year. If the unexplained fen retention figures are set aside, it is over £100,000 per kilogram. On phosphorus, the compensation measure that Natural England discounted (septic tank upgrades) appears to offer better value than the programme it chose. The comparison is approximate: both also buy nitrogen reduction, and the EDP budget buys habitat work as well.
Deer management is the largest recurring cost, at £175,000–£200,000 a year for 20 years and £25,000–£50,000 a year to year 100, and has no quantified nutrient benefit at all.
We ask Natural England to publish, for every selected and discounted measure, the whole-life cost, the expected reduction in kilograms a year with confidence ranges, and the resulting cost per kilogram, and to select measures on that basis.
Q24. Sequencing
To what extent do you agree with the proposed approach to sequencing of conservation measures?
Disagree
Under nutrient neutrality, mitigation had to be secured before occupation. Under this plan, harm begins when the first homes are occupied and benefit follows later, provided it arrives by the EDP end date. The draft accepts that fen creation and river restoration take years to become effective (p.68) and that sequencing is not fixed (para 175). Fen creation in the Yare, which supplies most of the quantified phosphorus benefit, is scheduled for Phase 2, and contiguous land use change for Phase 3, after 10,000 homes (Table 10). The programme is funded in arrears, as the levy is paid.
The literature on shallow lakes indicates that a new phosphorus equilibrium is reached only 10 to 15 years after loading falls (Jeppesen et al., 2007), longer than the plan period; here loading will rise. Natural England’s evidence review recorded time to effectiveness as a data field (Supplementary information 1, pp.1 and 4), but the draft does not reconcile it with the ten-year test. Under the Habitats Regulations, benefits not certain when consent is given cannot be relied on (Coöperatie Mobilisation, C-293/17 and C-294/17). That remains the standard private mitigation must meet.
We ask that:
- EDPs are paused and urgently reviewed to take account of the approach’s failure to acknowledge irreversible tipping-point risks for rare and irreplaceable habitats; in the meantime:
- no tranche of homes is released until verified reductions covering its load are in place;
- levy commitments are released in tranches tied to delivered, verified kilograms;
- new commitments pause automatically if delivery falls behind; and
- the sequencing table states, for each measure, its delivery date, the date its effect is expected, and the confidence in that date.
Q25. Delivery and procurement
To what extent do you agree with the proposed approach for the delivery (including procurement) of conservation measures?
Disagree
The approach builds in likely failures by design:
- Separate the roles: Natural England designs the plan, recommends that it passes the test, receives and spends the levy, procures and may deliver the measures, then monitors and reports on its own performance. It also sells nutrient credits in these catchments. Every land-based measure should be secured by a conservation covenant or equivalent agreement held by an independent Responsible Body, with independent verification of outcomes.
- Buy outcomes, not activities: Contracts should specify and pay for verified reductions in kilograms a year and for measured habitat condition, not hectares or tasks. Existing suppliers, including Norfolk Environmental Credits, Local Nutrient Mitigation Fund schemes, farmer groups and private providers, should be able to compete on equal terms against a pipeline published well in advance.
- Prevent leakage and double counting: Land use change agreements should bind connected land and businesses in the catchment, prohibit equivalent intensification elsewhere, and include clawback. The EDP should set stacking rules: whether EDP-funded habitat may also generate biodiversity units or carbon credits, and how that is recorded.
- Publish: Counterparties, locations, prices per kilogram, agreement terms and monitoring data should be public, so that additionality and leakage can be checked.
Compulsory purchase (para 183) should be a genuine last resort, never used where voluntary supply exists. Deer management should not be procured as a nutrient measure.
Chapter 7: Overall Improvement Test (Q26–Q28)
Q26. Methodology for the test
To what extent do you agree with the methodology for assessing the Overall Improvement Test?
Strongly disagree
The methodology lets the plan pass the ‘overall improvement test’ while the pressure that limits the protected sites increases.
- The overall improvement test ignores the impact it is intended to address: The test is said not to concern “the amount or extent of nutrient pollution” (p.75), and it does not consider agricultural pollution (para 8). The Act requires measures to address the environmental impact of development (s.61(3)(a)) and requires regard to conservation objectives that seek restored nutrient concentrations (s.94(5)).
- The overall improvement test has no threshold: HMG’s interpretation, supplied to Natural England by officials (para 714; Annex 7A), says there is “no minimum or fixed percentage”. A test with no threshold, scored by an unpublished panel, cannot be reproduced or falsified.
- The test ignores the ecologically limiting factors: Where nutrients limit recovery, as the plan’s evidence shows, gains in physical or biological components of a feature cannot outweigh a rise in the chemical one.
- Assumes deliverability: The Government’s guidance on the overall improvement test allows measures not yet secured to count where the market for them is “sufficiently liquid.” There is no indication of how this ‘liquidity’ is tested or assessed. Accessing land for environmental projects is not a ‘liquid’ market, as it is highly location dependent, and linked to the unique circumstances of the relevant landowners and land managers.
- Contagion risk: The supplemental information is intended to be “a standard approach to evidence reviews for EDPs for nutrient pollution” (p.1).
In our view the approach is ecologically illiterate: it counts activity that cannot be effective as recovery.
Q27. Strengthening the test
Would you suggest any improvements that can be made to strengthen the methodology for assessing the Overall Improvement Test?
We do not think the test as applied can be made sound by adjustment. If the plan proceeds, these should be the minimum requirements.
- Neutrality as a minimum, as promised: Quantified, verified reductions must at least equal the development load for each sub-catchment and nutrient, secured before occupation. Only then is improvement assessed.
- Quantified improvement: Improvement should be a stated margin in kilograms, set against each feature’s conservation objectives, not a scoring judgement. Natural England’s November 2025 prototype required 15%.
- An auditable method: Publish the calculations, models and scoring in a form others can rerun, as the statutory biodiversity metric allows for net gain.
- An independent, published panel: Publish members, declared interests, round-by-round scores and analysis.
- No trade-off of the limiting pressure: Gains in other components can only count once the chemical component shows no net increase.
- Sensitivity tests: Test the pre-2030 load scenario, growth in agricultural loads, lower uptake, delivery delays and failure of the fen retention assumption.
- Irreplaceable habitat: Where a feature is irreplaceable, compensation should not count towards the test.
- Ring-fencing: EDP benefits must not be used as headroom or mitigation for any other plan or project, or sold again as credits.
- Measured outcomes: Midpoint and endpoint reports should give measured loads and concentrations against pre-agreed thresholds, verified independently.
Q28. Evidence for the test
To what extent does the EDP clearly set out the evidence that underpins Natural England’s assessment of the Overall Improvement Test?
Not clear at all
The evidence for the plan’s largest single benefit is missing, and the consultation has now confirmed it.
Annex 7B attributes 325.9 kg of phosphorus a year to retention “by restored habitat” in 91 hectares of created fen in the Yare, and 39.89 kg to 18 hectares in the Bure (para 741). Together that is 365.8 kg, or 55% of the plan’s quantified phosphorus benefit. The only reference to how it was calculated was paragraph 858’s reference to a “conservation measure spatial targeting and nutrient reduction method document”.
Natural England’s document update now says that paragraph 858 “incorrectly references a document” and that the reference will be removed. It points instead to the measure specifications in Annex 6C, in particular paragraph 648 on land use change and the opportunity map at Figure 21. We can find no derivation of the fen retention figures there or anywhere else in the plan. The implied rates also differ between catchments without explanation (2.2 and 3.6 kg per hectare a year), and the same draft calls the nutrient benefit of fen creation in the Wensum “likely to be negligible” (para 831).
Other material is also missing:
- a reconciliation of the load figures in Annexes 5B and 7B;
- the Delphi panel’s membership, scores and analysis;
- the “in-depth review of effectiveness” by Natural England specialists (Supplementary information 1, p.7); and
- the levy cost model and the uptake evidence.
Supplementary information 1 also records that systematic searches covered two of five feature groups, that the targeted approach “introduces bias”, and that the appraisal was limited to qualitative categories for lack of time (pp.2, 4 and 7).
Natural England should publish the derivation or withdraw the figures, and rerun the test.
Chapter 8: Nature Restoration Levy (Q29–Q32)
Q29. Allocation of costs
To what extent do you agree that the allocation between (i) administration, (ii) delivery of conservation measure and (iii) long-term maintenance, (iv) management and (v) monitoring costs have been clearly set out?
Not very clear
The plan gives percentages only: 57% delivery, 20% maintenance, 17% apportioned administration, and 6% EDP-specific costs and monitoring (Figure 6). On a maximum levy of about £42.2 million (15,780 × £2,675), administration is about £7.2 million. Management is not shown separately, monitoring is combined with other costs, and nothing is shown by measure.
Private mitigation schemes build their prices from the bottom up: capital works, management for the life of the obligation, monitoring and reporting, covenant and legal costs, insurance or bonds, and a contingency for failure. As a Responsible Body, we price monitoring and enforcement over that whole period. The levy should be built and published the same way, so that it can be tested.
The long-term figures rest on a 2.05% discount rate over 100 years (paras 229–231). The plan does not say whether it is real or nominal, gives no sensitivity analysis, and does not say who covers a shortfall if returns disappoint.
We ask Natural England to publish the cost model, with explicit costs (not just expected percentages), by measure and by year, with its uptake, inflation and return assumptions, and with sensitivity tests for lower uptake, higher costs and failure of measures.
Q30. Likelihood of using or supplying the EDP
Based upon the cost alone how likely are you to use or supply services to the EDP compared to other available mechanisms, for example, local private providers, local planning authority schemes, bespoke mitigation etc?
Somewhat unlikely
We advise landowners, developers, land managers, corporates and NGOs. On the terms proposed, we could not advise landowners to commit land to EDP measures unless Natural England pays for verified outcomes at a price that reflects their full long-term cost, and secures them by covenant. Reputational issues around project failure would be enough to deter investors and other stakeholders that have been organising themselves around ecologically credible nature-markets, where buyers of nature-based solutions rightly expect to see properly funded and monitored results.
Q31. Speed of decision-making
To what extent do you agree that the proposed EDP will accelerate decision making and delivery timescales compared with alternative nutrient mitigation approaches?
Disagree
The plan removes project-level assessment, but it adds legal and regulatory risk, leaves development outside the plan reliant on a weakened mitigation market, and may need amending mid-plan if uptake or costs depart from the assumptions. Speed bought at the expense of the protected sites will not last.
Q32. A single, averaged levy
Do you agree with the approach taken to aggregating the costs of conservation measures at plan level and then apportioning these evenly across all development?
Strongly disagree
A flat charge breaks the link between what a home adds and what it pays. On the plan’s own figures, a home in the Bure adds between about 65% and 150% more phosphorus than a home in the Yare (paras 526–527 and 741), yet both pay £2,675, as do a one-bedroom flat and a five-bedroom house.
This has three effects.
- The plan removes every incentive to reduce load: There is no financial reason to connect to an upgraded works, install SuDS, cut water use or build where impacts are lower.
- The plan cross-subsidises the most damaging development: Homes with the lowest loads pay for those with the highest, contrary to the polluter-pays principle.
- The plan selects against itself: Developers compare the levy with the cost of verified mitigation. Where loads are high, mitigation costs more than £2,675 and the levy will be chosen; where loads are low, credits may be cheaper. The levy will therefore attract homes with higher loads than the average it is priced on, and the programme will be under-funded.
Natural England’s November 2025 prototype charged by the phosphorus permit of the receiving treatment works and by site size, from £3,200 to £60,500 per home, with a discount for SuDS. Charges should at least vary by sub-catchment and receiving works, and be set from the cost of verified reductions there.
Chapter 9: monitoring and reporting (Q33–Q34)
Q33. Monitoring themes
To what extent do you agree with the proposed monitoring themes as set out in chapter 9 of the EDP?
Disagree
The themes mainly track whether measures were delivered and money spent. For well-evidenced measures, ecological outcomes “may reasonably be inferred” from implementation (Annex 9A, para 863), attribution “may not always be feasible” (para 265), and monitoring falls away after year five and again after year 50 (paras 260–262). There are no water quality monitoring points within the wet woodland units (para 387). A plan whose central claims are unmeasured and monitored by inference cannot detect its own failure in time for back-up measures to work.
As a Responsible Body we would not accept that standard for a habitat bank, where biodiversity net gain sites report measured condition at fixed intervals for 30 years. The EDP should do at least as much. We propose:
- water quality monitoring (total phosphorus, total nitrogen, dissolved oxygen and chlorophyll-a) at fixed points for each feature, reported annually against targets;
- verification of the kilograms each measure removes, by measurement or by a published, audited method;
- leakage monitoring on land connected to land use change agreements;
- tracking of all new nutrient sources consented in the catchment, so the cumulative load is visible;
- tracking of demand for, and prices of, nutrient credits in the catchment, so market effects are visible;
- annual public reporting, independently verified, with data in open formats; and
- pre-agreed thresholds that trigger corrective action without waiting for the five-year report.
Q34. Reporting
To what extent does the EDP clearly set out how the reporting requirements will be met?
Not very clear
Midpoint and endpoint reports are described, but not what they will measure, who will verify them, or what follows if a report finds the plan is not on track to pass the test.
General (Q35–Q36)
Q35. Additional comments
Do you have any additional comments from the chapters above?
Our answers to Q6–Q34 set out our concerns with the plan. Here we address the consultation itself, the plan’s role as a template, and the standard Natural England applies to its own mitigation.
1. The consultation does not meet the Consultation Principles it says it follows
The consultation hub states that this consultation is conducted in line with the Cabinet Office Consultation Principles (2018). The Government’s announcement said the requirement to consult would let communities, developers and environmental groups “properly scrutinise” each plan before it is made. On the material published, that has not been possible.
Principle C: consultations should be informative: Consultees should be given enough information to understand the issues and give informed responses, with validated impact assessments where possible, particularly where proposals affect business. Here:
- the derivation of 55% of the quantified phosphorus benefit is not available, and the document update removes the only reference to it (Q28);
- the Delphi panel’s membership, scores and analysis, the in-depth effectiveness review, the levy cost model, the uptake evidence, and a reconciliation of the two sets of load figures are unpublished; and
- no impact assessment has been published, although the plan assumes it will take 80% of demand from an established market, including commitments made with public money (Q36).
The evidence base changed during the consultation: The document update on paragraph 858 is undated. It appears only as a note on the consultation hub; the GOV.UK consultation page records no update, and the note says the reference will be removed only from the final document. It does not say where the derivation of the fen retention figures can now be found. Anyone who responded before it was posted did so on the basis that a method document existed.
Principle E: consultations should last for a proportionate amount of time: Twenty-eight working days for a 255-page plan, with annexes and two supplementary documents, is not proportionate for the first plan of its kind and the template for 15 more, particularly after a mid-consultation change to the evidence.
Principle B: consult at a formative stage, not on settled views: HMG’s interpretation of the overall improvement test was supplied to Natural England by officials (para 714) and published as guidance on the day the consultation opened. The Government announced the plan as “going beyond neutrality”. Consultees are invited to comment on a framework presented as settled.
Principles I and J: scrutiny and timely response: We ask Natural England to publish all non-confidential responses, the number received, and how they changed the plan, and to do so before the Secretary of State decides. Consultees should be able to read the response before the six-week period for challenge under section 71 begins.
The legal standard: The Principles are not legally binding, but a consultation must still be fair. It must give sufficient information and reasons for intelligent consideration and response, allow adequate time, and be conscientiously taken into account (R v Brent LBC, ex p Gunning (1985) 84 LGR 168; R (Moseley) v Haringey LBC [2014] UKSC 56). Where a decision rests on a model or calculation, fairness can require enough disclosure for consultees to test it (R (Eisai Ltd) v NICE [2008] EWCA Civ 438). This is a statutory consultation under section 64 of the Planning and Infrastructure Act 2025, on a plan to which Article 7 of the Aarhus Convention applies.
What we ask: That the missing material is published, the draft plan is corrected, and the consultation window reopened for at least six weeks from publication.
2. A template for future plans
Natural England has notified 16 nutrient EDPs and 7 for great crested newts. The Government has committed not to make EDPs beyond nutrient pollution until it has made a statement to Parliament on the initial learnings from the first EDPs. The same learning should come before any further nutrient EDP is made, and it should be independent. We ask that the programme be urgently paused and reviewed, with the Office for Environmental Protection invited to advise on whether this approach is consistent with Part 3 of the Act and with the duty to take account of the best available scientific evidence (s.94(2)).
3. The standard Natural England applies to itself
Natural England already sells permanent nutrient credits in these catchments to Norfolk Environmental Credits: land reversion at Foxley Wood, Bawdeswell and Wood Norton, quantified in kilograms and secured by section 7 agreements and a conservation covenant, for 125 years at two of the sites. When Natural England sells mitigation to others, it meets the standard nutrient neutrality requires. When it spends levy money, the plan asks for no quantified neutrality at all. The EDP should meet the standard its author already applies. The lowering of standards, if that was the intention, should have been made legally visible on the face of the Planning and Infrastructure Bill when presented to Parliament as is required under Section 20(3) Environment Act 2021.
4. Conclusion
RSK Wilding fully supports landscape-scale nature recovery and strategic approaches to addressing environmental harms, of which there are many current successful examples. This plan would set the precedent that ecologically ineffective habitat management counts as recovery while pollution rises, and harms accelerates. This also sets a low-integrity benchmark, enabling public schemes to ignore laws that others need to follow, while undercutting verified mitigation by buying less of it. We urge Natural England not to recommend this to the Secretary of State in its current form. At its core, there can only be continued, and accelerated ecological degradation under the plan proposed.
Q36. Public Sector Equality Duty
We would like to hear about any potential impacts of any of the above proposals on businesses, or of any differential impact on persons with a relevant protected characteristic as defined by the Equality Act 2010 compared to persons without that protected characteristic, together with any appropriate mitigation measures, which may assist in deciding final policy approaches in due course. Is there anything that could be done to mitigate any impact identified?
The plan will have significant effects on the businesses and public bodies that supply nutrient mitigation, and none has been assessed. No economic or business impact assessment was published with the consultation.
Displacing existing businesses
The 80% uptake assumption rests on “emerging evidence” that the levy will be cheaper than alternative routes (Annex 3A, para 293). Market participants put the private cost of nutrient mitigation at £3,500 to £9,000 per home (Environmental Farmers Group) or £2,500 to £10,000 (Greenshank Environmental), depending on the catchment. The levy is £2,675, of which 77% funds measures. Applying Norfolk Environmental Credits’ lowest phosphorus credit price in the Yare (£5,420 plus VAT per 0.1 kg a year) to the plan’s own loads per home gives about £3,550 per home in the Yare and £5,870 in the Bure.
The levy is cheaper not because it delivers mitigation more efficiently, but because it buys less of it. On the plan’s own figures it leaves 29–39% of the added phosphorus and 83% of the added nitrogen unaddressed. Developers relying on private mitigation must satisfy a competent authority, project by project, that it leaves no reasonable scientific doubt. The levy replaces that test with a scored judgement, and the EDP itself is exempt from Habitats Regulations assessment and strategic environmental assessment (Schedule 5, paras 46 and 51). That is not competition on equal terms.
Commitments already made in these catchments
- Norfolk Environmental Credits, a not-for-profit company owned by Breckland, Broadland, North Norfolk, Norwich City and South Norfolk councils, awarded contracts worth £22 million in 2025 to two SME suppliers for 550 kg a year of permanent phosphorus reduction from septic tank upgrades.
- It has also agreed to buy permanent credits from Natural England’s own land reversion schemes, in a contract valued at £5 million, for about 111 kg of phosphorus and 2,324 kg of nitrogen a year, with options for more.
- Local Nutrient Mitigation Fund schemes, farmers and landowners have entered agreements that commit land for decades against demand the levy is expected to take.
These commitments were made in reliance on nutrient neutrality. If four-fifths of housing demand moves to the levy, public money is exposed, including through a council-owned company, and Natural England will be undercutting credits it is itself selling. None of this has been assessed.
Wider nature markets
Natural England has notified 15 further nutrient EDPs and 7 for great crested newts, without a published timetable. Investors cannot price the risk that demand for verified mitigation will be removed, at short notice, by a public levy set below its cost. Market participants already report that uncertainty. The same risk now attaches to biodiversity net gain habitat banks and to species mitigation. It sits uneasily with the Government’s statement that the plan will “create new opportunities for Norfolk farmers, landowners, and private organisations”, and it undermines the integrity standards the market has built: quantified outcomes, legal security and independent oversight.
Landowners
Natural England will be the dominant buyer of conservation measures in these catchments, setting prices from a fixed budget rather than from the cost of outcomes. It holds compulsory purchase powers (s.89) and proposes to use them as a last resort (para 183). Landowners already negotiating with developers or mitigation providers may find demand diverted or terms imposed.
Developers
The flat levy cross-subsidises high-load development and will attract it (Q32). Developers outside the plan, in excluded areas or building other kinds of accommodation, will depend on a market the levy has weakened.
Mitigation we propose
- Urgently pause and review the EDP programme to prevent unintended environmental and economic harm;
- Publish an economic and business impact assessment, including the uptake evidence and an analysis of effects on existing mitigation schemes, before the plan is made;
- Set the levy at the full cost of verified outcomes, differentiated by location, and independently reviewed (as is the case for Community Infrastructure Levies);
- Buy verified reductions from existing schemes first, on fair terms, with transitional arrangements for commitments already made;
- Publish a timetable and pricing basis for further EDPs;
- Rule out compulsory purchase where voluntary supply exists;
- Set clear stacking and additionality rules with biodiversity net gain and carbon markets.
Protected characteristics
We have not identified a direct differential effect on people with protected characteristics. A flat per-home levy does, however, charge a one-bedroom flat the same as a five-bedroom house. Natural England should consider whether that bears disproportionately on smaller and affordable homes, and on the people, including younger people, most likely to need them.